What’s Inside?
Hello everyone, Welcome back to MarketRead! Let’s start this article with an interesting analogy. For a farmer, understanding the right time to sow seeds, nurture the crops, and protect them from pests using pesticides is crucial. However, the key to getting the best price for the crops is to harvest them at the right time. If he harvests too early, the crops won’t be fully mature and won’t fetch the desired quality. If he waits too long, the crops may lose their quality.
Similarly, in mutual funds, knowing when to sell or exit the schemes is essential to earning good returns. Selling at the right time can maximize your profits, while selling at the wrong time can lead to suboptimal returns.
Read Also: Top 10 Mutual Funds for SIP to Invest
When Should You Exit a Mutual Fund?
Mutual fund investors often ask questions like:
- Should I sell my mutual funds to book profits?
- The stock market has crashed. Should I exit my mutual fund?
- My mutual fund hasn’t moved up or down. Should I sell?
These reasons may not always justify exiting your mutual fund investments. By booking profits, you may end up selling well-performing funds and holding onto the poorly performing ones. This approach can hinder your long-term returns. Let’s discuss some fundamental reasons for exiting a mutual fund.
1. Achieving Your Financial Goals
One primary reason to exit a mutual fund is when you are close to achieving your financial goals. For example, suppose you plan to buy a car worth ₹10 lakh within five years and have been investing ₹20,000 every month through a monthly SIP in an equity fund. If your equity fund generates an average return of 12%, you might accumulate the required amount in just four years. In this case, you can exit your mutual fund as you have achieved your financial goal earlier than expected.
2. Changes in Fund Fundamentals
An investor may choose a mutual fund that matches their risk profile. However, if the fund undergoes changes in its fundamentals, such as investment objectives or structure, it may no longer align with the investor’s risk tolerance. For example, Aditya Birla Sun Life Focused Fund used to invest in a maximum of 30 large-cap stocks, but from October 2023, it started investing across large, mid, and small-cap stocks. If an investor with low risk tolerance finds this change unsuitable, it might be a reason to exit the fund.
3. Underperformance of the Fund
If an equity fund consistently underperforms its benchmark and peers over three years, chances are it will continue to underperform in the future. For instance, funds like Franklin India Blue Chip Fund Direct Plan Growth and Taurus Flexi Cap Fund Direct Plan Growth have failed to beat their benchmarks over multiple time frames. Holding onto such funds delays your ability to cut losses and reallocate to better-performing funds.
4. Rebalancing Your Portfolio
Investors frequently need to rebalance their portfolios to keep up their desired asset allocation. For example, if your portfolio initially had 60% in equity funds and 40% in debt funds, but due to market changes, the equity portion rises to 70%, you might need to sell some equity funds to return to the original allocation. This helps in managing risk according to your investment objectives.
5. Facing a Financial Emergency
Unexpected financial emergencies, such as job loss or excessive medical expenses, may force you to exit your mutual funds. Experts recommend having an emergency fund equivalent to one year’s worth of living expenses. If you don’t have an emergency fund or have exhausted it, you may need to liquidate your mutual fund investments, even at a loss.
When Should You Wait Before Exiting Mutual Funds?
- Market Volatility: Exiting during a market crash can hinder your financial goals. Staying invested during market downturns can help maximize returns, as markets often recover. For example, investors who held on during the March 2020 crash saw significant gains after the market recovery.
- Out-of-Fashion Investment Styles: Mutual funds follow different investment styles, like growth or value investing. These styles can go through periods of underperformance. An out-of-favor investment style doesn’t necessarily mean you should exit. For instance, growth-focused funds may underperform during certain market cycles but can outperform over the long term.
Conclusion
Understanding when to exit a mutual fund is crucial but doesn’t have a one-size-fits-all answer. It depends on various factors like your investment horizon, risk appetite, and specific financial goals. Always investigate or counsel a money related advisor some time before making any speculation decisions.
If you found this article supportive, if you don’t mind, share the article.
Thank you for perusing, and see you in the following article.
Disclaimer: Mutual fund investments are subject to market risks. Please read the scheme documents carefully before investing. This article is for educational purposes only and should not be taken as direct investment advice.
FAQ: When is the Right Time to Exit a Mutual Fund?
1. Why is it important to exit a mutual fund at the right time?
Exiting a mutual fund at the right time ensures that you maximize your returns and achieve your financial goals. Exiting too early or too late can lead to suboptimal returns and potentially impact your financial planning.
2. What are some signs that it’s time to exit a mutual fund?
- Achieving Financial Goals: When you have accumulated the necessary amount for a specific financial goal.
- Changes in Fund Fundamentals: If the mutual fund undergoes significant changes that no longer align with your risk tolerance or investment strategy.
- Underperformance: If the mutual fund consistently underperforms its benchmark and peers over a significant period.
- Portfolio Rebalancing: When your portfolio’s asset allocation shifts significantly due to market movements.
- Financial Emergency: When you need immediate liquidity due to unforeseen financial crises.
3. How do I determine if my mutual fund is underperforming?
Compare the mutual fund’s performance with its benchmark and similar funds over multiple time frames (e.g., 3, 5, 10 years). Consistent underperformance relative to these benchmarks and peers indicates that the fund may continue to lag, and it might be wise to consider exiting.
4. What should I do if my financial goal is near but the market is volatile?
Market volatility can impact your investments significantly. If you are close to your financial goal, consider transferring your investments from equity funds to safer options like fixed deposits or liquid funds to protect your corpus from market fluctuations.
5. Can changes in a mutual fund’s investment objective be a reason to exit?
Yes, changes in the investment objective or structure of the fund can affect its suitability for your risk profile. For instance, if a fund that previously invested only in large-cap stocks starts investing in mid and small-cap stocks, it may no longer align with a conservative investor’s risk tolerance.
6. What is the impact of exiting a mutual fund during a market crash?
Exiting during a market crash can result in selling at a loss and missing out on potential recovery gains. Long-term investments in equity funds often yield better returns, so it’s usually better to stay invested unless there’s an urgent financial need.
7. How often should I rebalance my portfolio?
Rebalancing depends on market conditions and your investment strategy. Typically, it’s advisable to review your portfolio annually or semi-annually. If your asset allocation deviates significantly from your desired ratio due to market movements, it’s a good time to rebalance.
8. What are the tax implications of exiting a mutual fund?
Exiting a mutual fund may trigger capital gains tax. The tax rate depends on the type of fund (equity or debt) and the holding period. Consult a tax advisor to understand the specific implications for your situation.
9. Should I exit a mutual fund if its investment style is out of favor?
Not necessarily. Investment styles like growth or value can go through periods of underperformance. It’s important to understand the long-term potential of these styles and avoid making hasty decisions based on short-term trends.
10. How can I avoid the need to exit a mutual fund during a financial emergency?
Maintain an emergency fund equivalent to at least one year’s worth of living expenses. This can provide a financial cushion during emergencies, allowing you to avoid liquidating your mutual fund investments at an inopportune time.
11. What is the process for exiting a mutual fund?
You can exit a mutual fund by redeeming your units through your investment platform or mutual fund’s website. The redemption process typically involves selecting the number of units or amount to redeem and submitting a request. The funds are usually credited to your bank account within a few business days.
12. Should I consult a financial advisor before exiting a mutual fund?
Yes, consulting a financial advisor is advisable to ensure that your decision aligns with your overall financial plan and goals. A professional can provide personalized advice based on your unique situation.
For any further queries or detailed advice, always consider consulting a financial expert.
